There is one category of female ancestors that I neglected: What if you have more than one surname for your mystery lady?
Every now and then researchers will determine the maiden name of a female based on perfectly sound research. Yet another researcher will come along and, based on perfectly sound evidence, determine that a different surname should be associated with this woman. In some instances the earlier research will gain new popularity, bringing the debate to the forefront once again.
If this woman happens to be your ancestor, what do you do?
1) Acknowledge both research findings. State the arguments of each and record the sources used in each case.
2) Examine each source cited in both arguments. Look for strengths and weaknesses in each piece of evidence.
3) Make a timeline for both maiden names and the husband. See how the facts and assumptions fit with the chronology of the family.
4) Conduct your own research. Cross-check the "known sources." Look for new evidence. See what fits logically. Note the sources that are marginal or questionable in support of the argument each supported.
5) Make a sound, well-researched evaluation of the information on the woman in question and write up your arguments, pro and con. Write up your narrative explaining why you chose one surname over the other - with supporting evidence.
6) If the evidence does not sway you one way or the other, go back to #1 above. Present both sides in your narrative. Acknowledge that you feel there is not overwhelming evidence in support of either argument.
Wow! Tis is Blog post #1200!!😎
No comments:
Post a Comment